Replacement Sign Faces: Acrylic or Polycarbonate?
Free Shipping @ $149 Free Local Pickup Also Available
Follow Us On

Replacement Sign Faces: Acrylic or Polycarbonate?

When a lightbox or pylon sign face cracks, yellows or needs a new tenant’s graphics, the cabinet usually stays and only the face changes. The first decision is the sheet: acrylic or polycarbonate. This guide covers which material suits which sign, which thickness to order, how sheet size limits what you can cover in one piece, and how to put graphics on the new face.

The Short Answer

  • Acrylic for faces mounted out of reach: pole and pylon cabinets, wall-mounted lightboxes and channel letter faces. It gives a harder, glossier face at a lower cost, and it comes in larger sheets.
  • Polycarbonate for faces that can be hit: low monument signs, drive-thru and parking-lot signs, and anywhere vandalism or flying debris is a risk. It is shatter-resistant, where acrylic can crack.

For a full material comparison, including the plexiglass, Lucite and Lexan names, see our guide to polycarbonate vs acrylic for signs.

Acrylic vs Polycarbonate for Sign Faces

Question

AcrylicPolycarbonate
Where it belongsFaces mounted out of harm’s wayFaces that may take a hit
FaceHarder and glossier, resists scratching betterSofter, scratches more easily
ImpactMore impact resistant than glass, but can crackShatter-resistant; the safer choice where breakage is a risk
CostLowerHigher
OutdoorsUV-stableUV-stabilized, resists yellowing
Sheet sizes we stock4x8 in 1/8" and 3/16"; 4x10, 6x8, 5x10 and 6x10 in 3/16" White 73284x8 in 1/8" and 3/16"; larger sheets by order
Colors we stockClear and White 7328Clear and white
Laser cuttingCuts cleanly on a laserNot a laser material; the edge scorches

Match the Face to the Location

The location decides the material more than anything else.

  • High pole and pylon signs: acrylic. Nothing reaches the face, and its hard gloss keeps a cleaner look between cleanings.
  • Wall-mounted lightboxes above the door line: acrylic, for the same reasons.
  • Monument and ground-level signs: polycarbonate. These faces sit at bumper, cart and foot height.
  • Drive-thru, menu board and parking-lot signs: polycarbonate, where vehicles and snow removal come close.
  • Signs that have been broken before: polycarbonate. A face that was cracked once is likely to be hit again.

1/8" or 3/16"?

The cabinet decides first. The retainers and channels that hold the face are built for a set thickness, so a replacement face has to match what they hold. Measure the old face, or the retainer channel, before you order.

Where the retainers take either thickness, 1/8" suits faces held in a frame or cabinet on all sides. Choose 3/16" for larger faces and faces that need more rigidity. A thin face across a wide cabinet can bow in the wind and pop out of its retainers.

If the face has to survive a hit, the material matters more than the thickness. Polycarbonate is shatter-resistant, where acrylic can crack.

Sheet Size: Covering the Cabinet in One Piece

Sheet size matters on bigger cabinets. Acrylic in 3/16" White 7328 is stocked in 4x10, 6x8, 5x10 and 6x10 as well as 4x8, so a face larger than 4x8 can often be cut from a single acrylic sheet without a seam.

Polycarbonate is stocked in 4x8, and we can order larger sheets. If the face needs polycarbonate and the opening is larger than 4x8, call us about a larger sheet before you plan a seam.

Measuring for a Replacement Face

  • Measure the old face, not the visible opening. Part of the face sits hidden under the retainers.
  • Measure at more than one point. Older cabinets are not always square.
  • Note the thickness of the face you are removing.
  • Allow for expansion. Plastic faces grow and shrink with temperature, so a face cut tight to the frame on a cold day can buckle in summer.

Send us your sizes and we will cut the sheet down. We cut every substrate we sell to size, acrylic and polycarbonate included.

Graphics on a Lighted Face

  • Start with White 7328 acrylic on a lit cabinet. It is a common sign white for illuminated faces because it spreads LED light evenly.
  • Use translucent vinyl for colored graphics. Oracal 8500 translucent vinyl is ORAFOL’s backlit film for channel letter faces and sign boxes. Its satin finish diffuses light evenly without hot spots.
  • Use opaque vinyl only where you want light blocked. Standard sign vinyl like Oracal 651 looks dark at night on a lit face.
  • Consider applying graphics to the back of a clear face. Graphics on the inside surface are protected from weather and scratching.

Flat Faces vs Pan-Formed Faces

A flat face is cut straight from sheet and slides into the cabinet’s retainers. A pan-formed face is heated and formed with a raised flange around the edge, which adds depth and stiffness and is common on larger cabinets. We supply flat sheet, not pan-formed faces, and flat faces are what you can cut from our 4x8 and larger sheets.

Replacement Sign Faces: FAQ

What is the best material for a replacement sign face?

Acrylic for faces mounted out of reach, such as pole signs and wall lightboxes. Polycarbonate for faces that may be hit, such as monument, drive-thru and parking-lot signs.

Is Lexan good for sign faces?

Yes. Lexan is a brand name for polycarbonate, the shatter-resistant choice for sign faces in exposed locations. Our sign-grade polycarbonate is UV-stabilized for outdoor use.

What thickness should a sign face be?

Match the thickness the cabinet’s retainers hold. Where they take either, 1/8" suits faces held in a frame or cabinet, and 3/16" suits larger faces that need more rigidity.

What color acrylic is used for lighted sign faces?

White 7328 is a common sign white for illuminated faces. It spreads LED light evenly across lightbox panels and channel letter faces.

Can I get a sign face bigger than 4x8 in one piece?

Yes. We stock 3/16" White 7328 acrylic in 4x10, 6x8, 5x10 and 6x10 sheets. Polycarbonate is stocked in 4x8, and we can order larger sheets. Call 1-800-999-3160.

Do you sell pan-formed sign faces?

Not currently. We supply flat acrylic and polycarbonate sheet, cut to size for flat sign faces.

Can you cut a replacement sign face to size?

Yes. We cut every substrate we sell to size, including acrylic and polycarbonate. Contact us with your sizes.

What vinyl goes on a lighted sign face?

Use translucent vinyl, such as Oracal 8500, so light passes through the graphics. Opaque vinyl blocks the light and looks dark at night.

Order Sign Face Sheets

Central Sign Supplies is a family-owned distributor in Omaha, Nebraska, supplying sign shops since 1951. No wholesale account is required. Shop acrylic sign sheets and polycarbonate sign sheets, pick up full sheets at 4222 D St in Omaha, or call 1-800-999-3160 for cut sizes and a freight quote.